Techno-economic Analysis of Distributed Hydrogen Production from Natural Gas

Abstract

Abstract: It is well established that hydrogen has the potential to make a significant contribution to the world energy production.In U.S.,majority of hydrogen production plants implement steam methane reforming(SMR) for centralized hydrogen production.However,there is a wide lack of agreement on the nascent stage of using hydrogen as fuel in vehicles industry because of the difficulty in delivery and storage.By performing technological and economic analysis,this work aims to establish the most feasible hydrogen production pathway for automotives in near future.From the evaluation,processes such as thermal cracking of ammonia and centralized hydrogen production followed by bulk delivery are eliminated while on-site steam reforming of methanol and natural gas are the most technologically feasible options.These two processes are further evaluated by comprehensive economic analysis.The results showed that the steam reforming(SR) of natural gas has a shorter payback time and a higher return on investment(ROI) and internal rate of return(IRR).Sensitivity analysis has also been constructed to evaluate the impact of variables like NG feedstock price,capital of investment and operating capacity factor on the overall production cost of hydrogen.Based on this study,natural gas is prompted to be the most economically and technologically available raw material for short-term hydrogen production before the transition to renewable energy source such as solar energy,biomass and wind power.

Key words: gas station, cost analysis, steam reforming, ammonia cracking

摘要： It is well established that hydrogen has the potential to make a significant contribution to the world energy production.In U.S.,majority of hydrogen production plants implement steam methane reforming(SMR) for centralized hydrogen production.However,there is a wide lack of agreement on the nascent stage of using hydrogen as fuel in vehicles industry because of the difficulty in delivery and storage.By performing technological and economic analysis,this work aims to establish the most feasible hydrogen production pathway for automotives in near future.From the evaluation,processes such as thermal cracking of ammonia and centralized hydrogen production followed by bulk delivery are eliminated while on-site steam reforming of methanol and natural gas are the most technologically feasible options.These two processes are further evaluated by comprehensive economic analysis.The results showed that the steam reforming(SR) of natural gas has a shorter payback time and a higher return on investment(ROI) and internal rate of return(IRR).Sensitivity analysis has also been constructed to evaluate the impact of variables like NG feedstock price,capital of investment and operating capacity factor on the overall production cost of hydrogen.Based on this study,natural gas is prompted to be the most economically and technologically available raw material for short-term hydrogen production before the transition to renewable energy source such as solar energy,biomass and wind power.

关键词: gas station, cost analysis, steam reforming, ammonia cracking

LUK Ho Ting, LEI Ho Man, NG Wai Yee, LAM Koon Fung. Techno-economic Analysis of Distributed Hydrogen Production from Natural Gas[J]. , 2012, 20(3): 489-496.

References

1 Plunkett Research Ltd., "Automobile Industry Introduction", Plunkett Research, Ltd. (2011).
2 Dargay, J., Gately, D., Sommer, M., "Vehicle ownership and income growth", Energy J., 28, 1960-2030 (2007)
3 Attarian, J., "The coming end of cheap oil-To Hubbert's peak and beyond", The Social Contract, 276-286 (2002)
4 The U.S. Energy Information Administration, "U.S. Gasoline and Diesel Retail Prices", June 2011.
5 Office of Transportation and Air Quality, "Emission facts: Average carbon dioxide emissions resulting from gasoline and diesel fuel", Environmental Protection Agency, USA, EPA420-F-05-001 (2005).
6 Faungnawakij, K., Kikuchi, R., Eguchi, K., "Thermodynamic evaluation of methanol steam reforming for hydrogen production", J. Power Sources, 161, 87-94 (2006)
7 Matsumura, Y., Ishibe, H., "Effect of zirconium oxide added to Cu/ZnO catalyst for steam reforming of methanol to hydrogen", J. Mol. Catal. A: Chem., 345, 44-53 (2011).
8 Agarwal, V., Patel, S., Pant, K.K., "H₂ production by steam reforming of methanol over Cu/ZnO/Al₂O₃ catalysts: Transient deactivation kinetics modeling", Appl. Catal., A, 279, 155-164 (2005).
9 Christopher, B.J., Gulari, E., "Hydrogen production from methanol decomposition over Pt/Al₂O₃ and ceria promoted Pt/Al₂O₃ catalysts", Catal. Comm., 5, 431-436 (2004).
10 Cortright, R.D., Davda, R.R., Dumesic J.A., "Hydrogen from catalytic reforming of biomass-derived hydrocarbons in liquid water", Nature, 418, 964-967 (2002).
11 Chen, W.H., Syu, Y.J., "Thermal behavior and hydrogen production of methanol steam reforming and autothermal reforming with spiral preheating", Int. J. Hydrogen Energy, 36, 3397-3408 (2011).
12 Bernardo, P., Barbieri, G., Drioli, E., "Evaluation of membrane reactor with hydrogen-selective membrane in methane steam reforming", Chem. Eng. Sci., 65, 1159-1166 (2010).
13 De Castro, J., Rivera-Tinoco, R., Bouallou, C., "Hydrogen production from natural gas: Auto-thermal reforming and CO₂ Capture", Chem. Eng. Trans., 21, 163-168 (2010).
14 Appl, M., G ssling, H., "Production of synthesis gas after the steam reforming process", Chemiker Zeitung, 96 (3), 135-153 (1972).
15 Tarun, C.B., Croiset, E., Douglas, P.L., Gupta, M., Chowdhury, M.H.M., "Techno-economic study of CO₂ capture from natural gas based hydrogen plants", Int. J. Greenhouse Gas Control, 1, 5561 (2007).
16 Li, Q.F., He, R.H., Jensen, J.O., Bjerrum, N.J., "Approaches and recent development of polymer", Chem. Mater., 15, 4896-4915 (2003).
17 Wang, M., Li, J., Chen, L., Lu, Y., "Miniature NH 3 cracker based on microfibrous entrapped Ni-CeO₂/Al₂O₃ catalyst monolith for portable fuel cell power supplies", Int. J. Hydrogen Energy, 34, 1710-1716 (2009).
18 Thomas, G., Parks, G., "Potential Roles of Ammonia in a Hydrogen Economy. A Study of Issues Related to the Use Ammonia for On-Board Vehicular Hydrogen Storage", U.S. Department of Energy Report, 2006[2012-4-22] http://www.hydrogen.energy.gov/pdfs/nh3_paper.pdf
19 Pérez-Hernández, R., Gutiérrez-Martínez, A., Palacios, J.Vega-Hernández, M., Rodríguez-Lugo, V., "Hydrogen production by oxidative steam reforming of methanol over Ni/CeO₂ZrO₂ catalysts", Int. J. Hydrogen Energy, 36, 6601-6608 (2011).
20 Basile, A., Tereschenkob, G. F., Orekhova, N. V., Ermilova, M. M., Galluccia, F., Iulianellia, A., "An experimental investigation on methanol steam reforming with oxygen addition in a flat Pd-Ag membrane reactor", Int. J. Hydrogen Energy, 31, 1615-1622 (2006).
21 Yang, M., Li, S., Chen, G., "High-temperature steam reforming of methanol over ZnO-Al₂O₃ catalysts", Appl. Catal., B, 101, 409-416 (2011).
22 Yu, H., Chen, H., Pan, M., Tang, Y., Zeng, K., Peng, F., Wang, H., "Effect of the metal foam materials on the performance of methanol steam micro-reformer for fuel cells", Appl. Catal., A, 327, 106-113 (2007).
23 Fuel Cells 2000, "World hydrogen fueling stations", 2009 [2012-5-12], http://www.fuelcells.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/02/h2fuelingstations-worldl.pdf
24 Ogden, J. M., "Prospects for building a hydrogen energy infrastructure", Annu. Rev. Energy Env., 24, 227-279 (1999).
25 Eidelman, F., "Efficiency of internal combustion engine" Economy & Energy 1998 [2012-4-22] http://ecen.com/content/eee7/motoref.htm
26 Schlapbach, L., Z黷tel, A., "Hydrogen-storage materials for mobile application", Nature, 414, 353-358 (2001).
27 Wang, M.Q., Huang, H.S., "A full fuel-cycle analysis of energy and emissions impacts of transportation fuels produced from natural gas", US Department of Energy, Center for Transportation Research, Argonne National Laboratory, ANL/ESD-40 1999 [2012-4-22], http://www.transportation.anl.gov/pdfs/TA/13.pdf
28 The National Renewable Energy Laboratory, "Advanced technology and alternative fuel vehicles", U.S. Department of Energy, DOE/GO-102001-1142, FS143, 2011 [2012-4-22] http://www.nrel.gov/docs/fy01osti/27957.pdf
29 Szybist, J.P., Chakravathy, K., Stuart Daw, C., "Analysis of the impact of selected fuel thermochemical properties on internal combustion engine efficiency", Energy Fuels, DOI: 10.1021/ef2019879 (2012).
30 Ren, X., Zelenay, P., Thomas, S., Davey, J., Gottesfeld, S., "Recent advances in direct methanol fuel cells at Los Alamos National Laboratory", J. Power Sources, 86, 111-116 (2000).
31 Spath, P.L., Mann, M.K., "Life cycle assessment of hydrogen production via natural gas steam reforming", US Department of Energy, National Renewable Energy Laboratory report, NREL/TP-570-27637, 2001[2012-4-22] http://www-pord.ucsd.edu/~sgille/mae124_s06/27637.pdf
32 Hart, D., Hydrogen power-The Commercial Future of the Ultimate Fuel, Financial Times Energy Publishing, UK (1997).
33 Yu, H., Chen, H.Q., Pan, M.Q., Tang, Y., Zeng, K., Peng, F., Wang, H., "Effect of the metal foam materials on the performance of methanol steam micro-reformer for fuel cells", Appl. Catal., A, 327, 106-113 (2007).
34 Qadrdan, M., Shayegan, J., "Economic assessment of hydrogen fueling station, a case study for Iran", Renewable Energy, 33, 2525-2531 (2008).
35 Haryanto, A., Fernando, S., Murali, N., Adhikari, S., "Current status of hydrogen production techniques by steam reforming of ethanol: A review", Energy Fuels, 19, 2098-2106 (2005).
36 Natural Gas Organization, "Transportation of natural gas", Natural Gas.org, 2011 [2012-4-22], http://www.naturalgas.org/naturalgas/transport.asp
37 Aceves, S.M., Berry, G., Weisberg, A., "V.D Storage, FY 2005 progress report of DOE hydrogen program", 2005 [2012-5-16], http://www.hydrogen.energy.gov/pdfs/progress05/v_d_1_aceves.pdf
38 Kim, A.P., Stub Nielsen, C., J鵵gensen, S.L., "Membrane reforming for hydrogen", Catal. Today, 46, 193-201 (1998).
39 Wang, G., Ogden, J.M., Nicholas, M.A., "Lifecycle impacts of natural gas to hydrogen pathways on urban air quality", Int. J. Hydrogen Energy, 32, 2731-2742 (2007).
40 LI, L.X., Hurley, J. A., "Ammonia-based hydrogen source for fuel cell applications", Int. J. Hydrogen Energy, 32, 6-10 (2007).
41 Perry, R.H., Green, D.W., Perry's Chemical Engineers' Handbook, 7th edition, McGraw-Hill, New York (2007).
42 Stefanidis, G.D., Vlachos, D.G., "Methane steam reforming at microscales: Operation strategies for variable power output at millisecond contact times", AIChE J., 55, 180-191 (2009).
43 Bartels, J.R., Pate, M.B., Olson, N.K., "An economic survey of hydrogen production from conventional and alternative energy sources", Int. J. Hydrogen Energy, 35, 8371-8384 (2010).
44 Adamson, K.A., Pearson, P., "Hydrogen and methanol: A comparison of safety, economics, efficiencies and emissions", J. Power Sources, 86, 548-555 (2000).
45 Steward, D., "H2A Production Model Updates", US Department of Energy, National Renewable Energy Laboratory, 2011 [2012-4-22], http://www.hydrogen.energy.gov/pdfs/review11/pd089_steward_201 1_p.pdf
46 Stoll, R. E., von Linde, F., "Hydrogen-What are the costs?", Hydrocarbon Process., Int. Ed., 79, 42-46 (2000).
47 Chen, Y., Wang, Y., Xu, H., Xiong, G. "Efficient production of hydrogen from natural gas steam reforming in palladium membrane reactor", Appl. Catal., B, 81, 283-294 (2008).

[1]	Sinu Poolachira, Sivasubramanian Velmurugan. Graphene oxide/hydrotalcite modified polyethersulfone nanohybrid membrane for the treatment of lead ion from battery industrial effluent [J]. Chinese Journal of Chemical Engineering, 2023, 60(8): 253-261.
[2]	Yishuang Wang, Na Li, Mingqiang Chen, Defang Liang, Chang Li, Quan Liu, Zhonglian Yang, Jun Wang. Glycerol steam reforming over hydrothermal synthetic Ni-Ca/attapulgite for green hydrogen generation [J]. Chinese Journal of Chemical Engineering, 2022, 48(8): 176-190.
[3]	Haocui Zhang, Zhourong Xiao, Mei Yang, Jijun Zou, Guozhu Liu, Xiangwen Zhang. Highly dispersible cerium-oxide modified Ni/SBA-15 for steam reforming of bio-mass based JP10 [J]. Chinese Journal of Chemical Engineering, 2022, 43(3): 255-265.
[4]	Chen Xu, Zhenyi Du, Shiqi Yang, Hongda Ma, Jie Feng. Effects of inherent potassium on the catalytic performance of Ni/biochar for steam reforming of toluene as a tar model compound [J]. Chinese Journal of Chemical Engineering, 2021, 35(7): 189-195.
[5]	Ammaru Ismaila, Huanhao Chen, Yan Shao, Shaojun Xu, Yilai Jiao, Xueli Chen, Xin Gao, Xiaolei Fan. Renewable hydrogen production from steam reforming of glycerol (SRG) over ceria-modified γ-alumina supported Ni catalyst [J]. Chinese Journal of Chemical Engineering, 2020, 28(9): 2328-2336.
[6]	Huangang Shi, Qianjun Li, Wenyi Tan, Hao Qiu, Chao Su. Solid oxide fuel cells in combination with biomass gasification for electric power generation [J]. Chinese Journal of Chemical Engineering, 2020, 28(4): 1156-1161.
[7]	Ashutosh Kumar, Ram Prasad, Yogesh Chandra Sharma. Ethanol steam reforming study over ZSM-5 supported cobalt versus nickel catalyst for renewable hydrogen generation [J]. Chinese Journal of Chemical Engineering, 2019, 27(3): 677-684.
[8]	Chun Shen, Wuqing Zhou, Hao Yu, Le Du. Ni nanoparticles supported on carbon as efficient catalysts for steam reforming of toluene (model tar) [J]. Chin.J.Chem.Eng., 2018, 26(2): 322-329.
[9]	YuWan, Zhiming Zhou, Zhenmin Cheng. Hydrogen production from steam reforming of methanol over CuO/ZnO/Al₂O₃ catalysts: Catalytic performance and kinetic modeling [J]. , 2016, 24(9): 1186-1194.
[10]	Yang Qi, Zhenmin Cheng, Zhiming Zhou. Steam reforming of methane over Ni catalysts prepared from hydrotalcite-type precursors: Catalytic activity and reaction kinetics [J]. Chin.J.Chem.Eng., 2015, 23(1): 76-85.
[11]	WANG Baowei, SUN Qimei, LÜ Yijun, YANG Meilin, YAN Wenjuan. Steam Reforming of Dimethyl Ether by Gliding Arc Gas Discharge Plasma for Hydrogen Production [J]. Chin.J.Chem.Eng., 2014, 22(1): 104-112.
[12]	FENG Dongmei, ZUO Yizan, WANG Dezheng, WANG Jinfu. Steam Reforming of Dimethyl Ether over Coupled Catalysts of CuO-ZnO-Al₂O₃-ZrO₂ and Solid-acid Catalyst [J]. , 2009, 17(1): 64-71.
[13]	JIANG Yuanli, LIM Mee Sook, KIM Dong Hyun. Simulation Studies of the Hydrogen Production from Methanol Partial Oxidation Steam Reforming by a Tubular Packed-bed Catalytic Reactor [J]. , 2001, 9(3): 297-305.