Process synthesis for the separation of coal-to-ethanol products

doi:10.1016/j.cjche.2023.12.019

摘要/Abstract

摘要： The coal-to-ethanol process, as the clean coal utilization, faces challenges from the energy-intensive distillation that separates multi-component effluents for pure ethanol. Referring to at least eight columns, the synthesis of the ethanol distillation system is impracticable for exhaustive comparison and difficult for conventional superstructure-based optimization as rigorous models are used. This work adopts a superstructure-based framework, which combines the strategy that adaptively selects branches of the state-equipment network and the parallel stochastic algorithm for process synthesis. High-performance computing significantly reduces time consumption, and the adaptive strategy substantially lowers the complexity of the superstructure model. Moreover, parallel computing, elite search, population redistribution, and retention strategies for irrelevant parameters are used to improve the optimization efficiency further. The optimization terminates after 3000 generations, providing a flowsheet solution that applies two non-sharp splitting options in its distillation sequence. As a result, the 59-dimension superstructure-based optimization was solved efficiently via a differential evolution algorithm, and a high-quality solution with a 28.34% lower total annual cost than the benchmark was obtained. Meanwhile, the solution of the superstructure-based optimization is comparable to that obtained by optimizing a single specific configuration one by one. It indicates that the superstructure-based optimization that combines the adaptive strategy can be a promising approach to handling the process synthesis of large-scale and complex chemical processes.

关键词: Coal-to-ethanol, Process synthesis, Superstructure-based optimization, Differential evolution algorithm, Distillation

Abstract: The coal-to-ethanol process, as the clean coal utilization, faces challenges from the energy-intensive distillation that separates multi-component effluents for pure ethanol. Referring to at least eight columns, the synthesis of the ethanol distillation system is impracticable for exhaustive comparison and difficult for conventional superstructure-based optimization as rigorous models are used. This work adopts a superstructure-based framework, which combines the strategy that adaptively selects branches of the state-equipment network and the parallel stochastic algorithm for process synthesis. High-performance computing significantly reduces time consumption, and the adaptive strategy substantially lowers the complexity of the superstructure model. Moreover, parallel computing, elite search, population redistribution, and retention strategies for irrelevant parameters are used to improve the optimization efficiency further. The optimization terminates after 3000 generations, providing a flowsheet solution that applies two non-sharp splitting options in its distillation sequence. As a result, the 59-dimension superstructure-based optimization was solved efficiently via a differential evolution algorithm, and a high-quality solution with a 28.34% lower total annual cost than the benchmark was obtained. Meanwhile, the solution of the superstructure-based optimization is comparable to that obtained by optimizing a single specific configuration one by one. It indicates that the superstructure-based optimization that combines the adaptive strategy can be a promising approach to handling the process synthesis of large-scale and complex chemical processes.

Key words: Coal-to-ethanol, Process synthesis, Superstructure-based optimization, Differential evolution algorithm, Distillation

Qingping Qu, Daoyan Liu, Hao Lyu, Jinsheng Sun. Process synthesis for the separation of coal-to-ethanol products[J]. 中国化学工程学报, 2024, 69(5): 263-278.

Qingping Qu, Daoyan Liu, Hao Lyu, Jinsheng Sun. Process synthesis for the separation of coal-to-ethanol products[J]. Chinese Journal of Chemical Engineering, 2024, 69(5): 263-278.

参考文献

[1] X.G. San, Y. Zhang, W.J. Shen, N. Tsubaki, New synthesis method of ethanol from dimethyl ether with a synergic effect between the zeolite catalyst and metallic catalyst, Energy Fuels 23(5)(2009)2843-2844.
[2] V. Subramani, S.K. Gangwal, A review of recent literature to search for an efficient catalytic process for the conversion of syngas to ethanol, Energy Fuels 22(2)(2008)814-839.
[3] H. Zhou, W.L. Zhu, L. Shi, H.C. Liu, S.P. Liu, S.T. Xu, Y.M. Ni, Y. Liu, L.N. Li, Z.M. Liu, Promotion effect of Fe in mordenite zeolite on carbonylation of dimethyl ether to methyl acetate, Catal. Sci. Technol. 5(3)(2015)1961-1968.
[4] J.J. Li, Y.L. Zhang, Y.L. Yang, X.M. Zhang, N.N. Wang, Y.H. Zheng, Y.J. Tian, K.C. Xie, Life cycle assessment and techno-economic analysis of ethanol production via coal and its competitors:A comparative study, Appl. Energy 312(2022)118791.
[5] X.Y. Xu, Y. Liu, F. Zhang, W. Di, Y.L. Zhang, Clean coal technologies in China based on methanol platform, Catal. Today 298(2017)61-68.
[6] J.J. Li, W.J. Cheng, Comparison of life-cycle energy consumption, carbon emissions and economic costs of coal to ethanol and bioethanol, Appl. Energy 277(2020)115574.
[7] S.Y. Huang, Y. Wang, J. Lü, Y.J. Zhao, S.P. Wang, X.B. Ma, Advances in indirect synthesis of ethanol from syngas via dimethyl ether/methyl acetate, CIESC J 67(1)(2016)240-247.(in Chinese)
[8] H. Wang, Z.L. Wu, Z.J. Tai, R.Y. Pei, X.G. Ren, Advances in synthesis of anhydrous ethanol from syngas via carbonylation of dimethyl ether and hydrogenation of methyl acetate, Chem. Ind. Eng. Prog. 38(10)(2019)4497-4503.
[9] C. Hua, H. Wang, P. Lu, J. Chen, F. Bai, A separation device and method for coal-to-ethanol liquid phase products, CN Pat., 111377800A, Tianjin, 2022.
[10] J. Sun, D. Liu, J. Wang, A novel separation device and separation method for coal-to-ethanol liquid phase products Beijing:CN114225456A, 2020-07-07.
[11] D.Y. Liu, H. Lyu, J.H. Wang, C.T. Cui, J.S. Sun, Comparison of coal-to-ethanol product separation strategies, Sep. Purif. Technol. 301(2022)121968.
[12] A. Aggarwal, C.A. Floudas, Synthesis of general distillation sequences-nonsharp separations, Comput. Chem. Eng. 14(6)(1990)631-653.
[13] L. Mencarelli, Q. Chen, A. Pagot, I.E. Grossmann, A review on superstructure optimization approaches in process system engineering, Comput. Chem. Eng. 136(2020)106808.
[14] H. Yeomans, I.E. Grossmann, A systematic modeling framework of superstructure optimization in process synthesis, Comput. Chem. Eng. 23(6)(1999)709-731.
[15] E.M.B. Smith, C.C. Pantelides, Design of reaction/separation networks using detailed models, Comput. Chem. Eng. 19(1995)83-88.
[16] G.R. Kocis, I.E. Grossmann, Global optimization of nonconvex mixed-integer nonlinear programming (MINLP) problems in process synthesis, Ind. Eng. Chem. Res. 27(8)(1988)1407-1421.
[17] S. Zhang, Y.Q. Luo, X.G. Yuan, Synthesis of simultaneously heat integrated and thermally coupled nonsharp distillation sequences based on stochastic optimization, Comput. Chem. Eng. 127(2019)158-174.
[18] J. Leboreiro, J. Acevedo, Processes synthesis and design of distillation sequences using modular simulators:A genetic algorithm framework, Comput. Chem. Eng. 28(8)(2004)1223-1236.
[19] W.Z. An, X.G. Yuan, A simulated annealing-based approach to the optimal synthesis of heat-integrated distillation sequences, Comput. Chem. Eng. 33(1)(2009)199-212.
[20] S. Lee, J.S. Logsdon, M.J. Foral, I.E. Grossmann, Superstructure optimization of the olefin separation process, Comput. Aided Chem. Eng. 14(2003)191-196.
[21] F. Trespalacios, I. Grossmann, Review of mixed-integer nonlinear and generalized disjunctive programming methods, Chem. Ing. Tech. 86(7)(2014)991-1012.
[22] H. Lyu, X.D. Zhang, C.T. Cui, J.S. Sun, Adaptive superstructure for multiple-interconnection process synthesis:Eliminate unnecessary flowsheet predetermination to reduce complexity, Chem. Eng. Process. Process. Intensif. 171(2022)108731.
[23] H. Lyu, S.H. Li, C.T. Cui, X.G. Yu, J.S. Sun, Superstructure modeling and stochastic optimization of side-stream extractive distillation processes for the industrial separation of benzene/cyclohexane/cyclohexene, Sep. Purif. Technol. 257(2021)117907.
[24] X.D. Zhang, L. Jin, H. Lyu, J. He, J.S. Sun, Optimal synthesis of quaternary zeotropic distillation sequences using an array formulation, Ind. Eng. Chem. Res. 61(51)(2022)18821-18832.
[25] S. Das, P.N. Suganthan, Differential evolution:A survey of the state-of-the-art, IEEE Trans. Evol. Comput. 15(1)(2011)4-31.
[26] W.L. Luyben, I.L. Chien, Design and Control of Distillation Systems for Separating Azeotropes. John Wiley&Sons, Inc., 2010.
[27] J.H. Wang, H. Lyu, D.Y. Liu, C.T. Cui, J.S. Sun, Optimization and simultaneous heat integration design of a coal-based ethylene glycol refining process by a parallel differential evolution algorithm, Front. Chem. Sci. Eng. 17(9)(2023)1280-1288.
[28] J. Leboreiro, J. Acevedo, Processes synthesis and design of distillation sequences using modular simulators:A genetic algorithm framework, Comput. Chem. Eng. 28(8)(2004)1223-1236.
[29] X.D. Zhang, L. Jin, J.S. Sun, Optimal synthesis of heat-integrated distillation configurations using the two-column superstructure, Chin. J. Chem. Eng.(2023).
[30] L. Jin, X.D. Zhang, C.T. Cui, Z.J. Xi, J.S. Sun, Simultaneous process parameters and heat integration optimization for industrial organosilicon production, Sep. Purif. Technol. 265(2021)118520.
[31] H. Lyu, C.T. Cui, X.D. Zhang, J.S. Sun, Population-distributed stochastic optimization for distillation processes:Implementation and distribution strategy, Chem. Eng. Res. Des. 168(2021)357-368.
[32] O. Yeniay, Penalty function methods for constrained optimization with genetic algorithms, Math. Comput. Appl. 10(1)(2005)45-56.