Environmental, economic and exergy analysis of separation of ternary azeotrope by variable pressure extractive distillation based on multi-objective optimization

doi:10.1016/j.cjche.2023.07.010

摘要/Abstract

摘要： In this work, the ternary azeotrope of tert-butyl alcohol/ethyl acetate/water is separated by extractive distillation (ED) to recover the available constituents and protect the environment. Based on the conductor like shielding model and relative volatility method, ethylene glycol was selected as the extractant in the separation process. In addition, in view of the characteristic that the relative volatility between components changes with pressure, the multi-objective optimization method based on nondominated sorting genetic algorithm II optimizes the pressure and the amount of solvent cooperatively to avoid falling into the optimal local solution. Based on the optimal process parameters, the proposed heat-integrated process can reduce the gas emissions by 29.30%. The heat-integrated ED, further coupled with the pervaporation process, can reduce gas emission by 42.36% and has the highest exergy efficiency of 47.56%. In addition, based on the heat-integrated process, the proposed two heat pump assisted heat-integrated ED processes show good economic and environmental performance. The double heat pump assisted heat-integrated ED can reduce the total annual cost by 28.78% and the gas emissions by 55.83% compared with the basis process, which has a good application prospect. This work provides a feasible approach for the separation of ternary azeotropes.

关键词: Extractive distillation, Optimization, Mixtures, Separation

Abstract: In this work, the ternary azeotrope of tert-butyl alcohol/ethyl acetate/water is separated by extractive distillation (ED) to recover the available constituents and protect the environment. Based on the conductor like shielding model and relative volatility method, ethylene glycol was selected as the extractant in the separation process. In addition, in view of the characteristic that the relative volatility between components changes with pressure, the multi-objective optimization method based on nondominated sorting genetic algorithm II optimizes the pressure and the amount of solvent cooperatively to avoid falling into the optimal local solution. Based on the optimal process parameters, the proposed heat-integrated process can reduce the gas emissions by 29.30%. The heat-integrated ED, further coupled with the pervaporation process, can reduce gas emission by 42.36% and has the highest exergy efficiency of 47.56%. In addition, based on the heat-integrated process, the proposed two heat pump assisted heat-integrated ED processes show good economic and environmental performance. The double heat pump assisted heat-integrated ED can reduce the total annual cost by 28.78% and the gas emissions by 55.83% compared with the basis process, which has a good application prospect. This work provides a feasible approach for the separation of ternary azeotropes.

Key words: Extractive distillation, Optimization, Mixtures, Separation

Peizhe Cui, Jiafu Xing, Chen Li, Mengjin Zhou, Jifu Zhang, Yasen Dai, Limei Zhong, Yinglong Wang. Environmental, economic and exergy analysis of separation of ternary azeotrope by variable pressure extractive distillation based on multi-objective optimization[J]. 中国化学工程学报, 2024, 65(1): 145-157.

参考文献

[1] D. Ren, S.P. Ren, Y.K. Lin, J.H. Xu, X.L. Wang, Recent developments of organic solvent resistant materials for membrane separations, Chemosphere 271(2021)129425.
[2] Y.T. Zhao, T.R. Zhao, H. Jia, X. Li, Z.Y. Zhu, Y.L. Wang, Optimization of the composition of mixed entrainer for economic extractive distillation process in view of the separation of tetrahydrofuran/ethanol/water ternary azeotrope, J. Chem. Technol. Biotechnol. 92(9)(2017)2433-2444.
[3] Z.Y. Zhu, S.H. Li, D.P. Meng, H.Q. Qi, F. Zhao, X. Li, P.Z. Cui, Y.L. Wang, D.M. Xu, Y. X. Ma, Energy efficient and environmentally friendly pervaporation-distillation hybrid process for ternary azeotrope purification, Comput. Chem. Eng. 147(2021)107236.
[4] K.M. Lo, I.L. Chien, Efficient separation method for tert-butanol dehydration via extractive distillation, J. Taiwan Inst. Chem. Eng. 73(2017)27-36.
[5] L. Zhao, X.Y. Lyu, W.C. Wang, J. Shan, T. Qiu, Comparison of heterogeneous azeotropic distillation and extractive distillation methods for ternary azeotrope ethanol/toluene/water separation, Comput. Chem. Eng. 100(2017)27-37.
[6] S.S. Liang, Y.J. Cao, X.Z. Liu, X. Li, Y.T. Zhao, Y.K. Wang, Y.L. Wang, Insight into pressure-swing distillation from azeotropic phenomenon to dynamic control, Chem. Eng. Res. Des. 117(2017)318-335.
[7] T. Akinciturk, D.B. Kaymak, Design and control of an energy-efficient triplecolumn pressure swing distillation configuration for separation of acetonemethanol-hexane mixture, Comput. Chem. Eng. 160(2022)107731.
[8] Q.J. Zhang, M.L. Liu, C. Li, A.W. Zeng, Design and control of extractive distillation process for separation of the minimum-boiling azeotrope ethylacetate and ethanol, Chem. Eng. Res. Des. 136(2018)57-70.
[9] Z.Y. Zhu, G.X. Li, Y. Dai, P.Z. Cui, D.M. Xu, Y.L. Wang, Determination of a suitable index for a solvent via two-column extractive distillation using a heuristic method, Front. Chem. Sci. Eng. 14(5)(2020)824-833.
[10] Y. An, W.S. Li, Y. Li, S.Y. Huang, J. Ma, C.L. Shen, C.J. Xu, Design/optimization of energy-saving extractive distillation process by combining preconcentration column and extractive distillation column, Chem. Eng. Sci. 135(2015)166-178.
[11] X.Q. You, J.L. Gu, V. Gerbaud, C.J. Peng, H.L. Liu, Optimization of preconcentration, entrainer recycle and pressure selection for the extractive distillation of acetonitrile-water with ethylene glycol, Chem. Eng. Sci. 177(2018)354-368.
[12] Y. Cui, Z.S. Zhang, X.J. Shi, C. Guang, J. Gao, Triple-column side-stream extractive distillation optimization via simulated annealing for the benzene/isopropanol/water separation, Sep. Purif. Technol. 236(2020)116303.
[13] S. Tututi-Avila, N. Medina-Herrera, J. Hahn, A. Jiménez-Gutiérrez, Design of an energy-efficient side-stream extractive distillation system, Comput. Chem. Eng. 102(2017)17-25.
[14] B. Kiran, A.K. Jana, Thermal integration of vapor recompression in a heatintegrated distillation:Impact of multiple intermediate reboilers, Chem. Eng. Res. Des. 114(2016)171-179.
[15] L. Jin, X.D. Zhang, C.T. Cui, Z.J. Xi, J.S. Sun, Simultaneous process parameters and heat integration optimization for industrial organosilicon production, Sep. Purif. Technol. 265(2021)118520.
[16] T. Shi, W. Chun, A. Yang, S.M. Jin, W.F. Shen, J.Z. Ren, J.L. Gu, The process control of the triple-column pressure-swing extractive distillation with partial heat integration, Sep. Purif. Technol. 238(2020)116416.
[17] N. Khalili, N. Kasiri, J. Ivakpour, A. Khalili-Garakani, M.H. Khanof, Optimal configuration of ternary distillation columns using heat integration with external heat exchangers, Energy 191(2020)116479.
[18] X. Jian, J.L. Li, Q. Ye, L.Q. Yan, X.H. Li, J.Y. Zhang, Process synthesis of intensified extractive distillation for recycling organics material from wastewater, Sep. Purif. Technol. 303(2022)122172.
[19] P.Y. Shi, Q.J. Zhang, A.W. Zeng, Y.G. Ma, X.G. Yuan, Eco-efficient vapor recompression-assisted pressure-swing distillation process for the separation of a maximum-boiling azeotrope, Energy 196(2020)117095.
[20] Q.J. Zhang, M.L. Liu, W. Li, C. Li, A.W. Zeng, Heat-integrated triple-column pressure-swing distillation process with multi-recycle streams for the separation of ternary azeotropic mixture of acetonitrile/methanol/benzene, Sep. Purif. Technol. 211(2019)40-53.
[21] X.M. Suo, Q. Ye, R. Li, X. Dai, H. Yu, The partial heat-integrated pressure-swing reactive distillation process for transesterification of methyl acetate with isopropanol, Chem. Eng. Process. 107(2016)42-57.
[22] D.Y. Sun, L.J. Gao, R.P. Wei, J. Zhang, X.M. Pan, G.M. Xiao, Process design, economic optimization, and environmental assessment for the production of glycerol carbonate via reactive distillation combined with pervaporation, Ind. Eng. Chem. Res. 61(44)(2022)16552-16564.
[23] A. Tgarguifa, S. Abderafi, T. Bounahmidi, Energy efficiency improvement of a bioethanol distillery, by replacing a rectifying column with a pervaporation unit, Renew. Energy 122(2018)239-250.
[24] Q. Li, A.A. Kiss, Novel pervaporation-assisted pressure swing reactive distillation process for intensified synthesis of dimethyl carbonate, Chem. Eng. Process. 162(2021)108358.
[25] A. Yang, Y. Su, I.L. Chien, S.M. Jin, C.L. Yan, S.A. Wei, W.F. Shen, Investigation of an energy-saving double-thermally coupled extractive distillation for separating ternary system benzene/toluene/cyclohexane, Energy 186(2019)115756.
[26] H. Alcocer-García, J.G. Segovia-Hernández, O.A. Prado-Rubio, E. SánchezRamírez, J.J. Quiroz-Ramírez, Multi-objective optimization of intensified processes for the purification of levulinic acid involving economic and environmental objectives, Chem. Eng. Process. 136(2019)123-137.
[27] J.L. Yan, J.Y. Liu, J.Y. Ren, Y. Wu, X.N. Li, T. Sun, L.Y. Sun, Design and multiobjective optimization of hybrid reactive-extractive distillation process for separating wastewater containing benzene and isopropanol, Sep. Purif. Technol. 290(2022)120915.
[28] X.Q. You, T.J. Ma, T. Qiu, Design and optimization of sustainable pressure swing distillation for minimum-boiling azeotrope separation, Ind. Eng. Chem. Res. 58(47)(2019)21659-21670.
[29] Y.D. Li, Q. Ye, N.G. Wang, L.J. Chen, H.X. Zhang, Y.G. Xu, Energy-efficient extractive distillation combined with heat-integrated and intermediate reboilers for separating acetonitrile/isopropanol/water mixture, Sep. Purif. Technol. 262(2021)118343.
[30] H.S. Varyemez, D.B. Kaymak, Effect of operating pressure on design of extractive distillation process separating DMC-MeOH azeotropic mixture, Chem. Eng. Res. Des. 177(2022)108-116.
[31] X.M. Qiu, B.J. Huo, Q. Wang, J.W. Yang, Z.Y. Zhu, Y.L. Wang, J. Gao, Isobaric vapor-liquid equilibrium of binary systems of 1-pentanol+butyl butyrate, 1-pentanol+N-formylmorpholine, and p-xylene+butyl butyrate at 101.3 kPa, J. Chem. Eng. Data 66(7)(2021)2874-2881.
[32] X.J. Shi, X.Y. Zhu, X.X. Zhao, Z.S. Zhang, Performance evaluation of different extractive distillation processes for separating ethanol/tert-butanol/water mixture, Process Saf. Environ. Prot. 137(2020)246-260.
[33] G.Z. Chen, Z. Song, Z.W. Qi, Transformer-convolutional neural network for surface charge density profile prediction:Enabling high-throughput solvent screening with COSMO-SAC, Chem. Eng. Sci. 246(2021)117002.
[34] B. Yang, Y.Q. Cheng, K. Chen, Z. Wei, Z.G. Lei, G.X. Li, Ester hydrolysis to alcohol using a combined reactive and extractive distillation with ionic liquids-based mixed solvents, Fuel 327(2022)125131.
[35] S.D. Gao, C.M. Bo, J. Li, C. Niu, X.H. Lu, Multi-objective optimization and dynamic control of biogas pressurized water scrubbing process, Renew. Energy 147(2020)2335-2344.
[36] W.L. Luyben, Design and control of the ethyl benzene process, AIChE J 57(3)(2011)655-670.
[37] X.B. Liu, X. Yang, M.X. Yu, W.X. Zhang, Y.L. Wang, P.Z. Cui, Z.Y. Zhu, Y.X. Ma, J. Gao, Energy, exergy, economic and environmental (4E) analysis of an integrated process combining CO₂ capture and storage, an organic Rankine cycle and an absorption refrigeration cycle, Energy Convers. Manag. 210(2020)112738.
[38] A. Bejan, G. Tsatsaronis, M.J. Moran, Thermal Design and Optimization, Wiley, NewYork, 1996.
[39] T.V. Nguyen, M. Voldsund, B. Elmegaard, I.S. Ertesvåg, S. Kjelstrup, On the definition of exergy efficiencies for petroleum systems:Application to offshore oil and gas processing, Energy 73(2014)264-281.
[40] Y.G. Xu, J.L. Li, Q. Ye, Y.D. Li, Design and optimization for the separation of tetrahydrofuran/isopropanol/water using heat pump assisted heat-integrated extractive distillation, Sep. Purif. Technol. 277(2021)119498.
[41] D.H. Zhang, Z.Y. Ren, C.S. Koh, Optimal design of powder-aligning and magnetizing fixtures for an anisotropic-bonded NdFeB permanent magnet, IEEE Trans. Magn. 50(2)(2014)697-700.
[42] J. Tang, K.K. Sirkar, S. Majumdar, Permeation and sorption of organic solvents and separation of their mixtures through an amorphous perfluoropolymer membrane in pervaporation, J. Membr. Sci. 447(2013)345-354.
[43] Y. Wang, T.S. Chung, B.W. Neo, M. Gruender, Processing and engineering of pervaporation dehydration of ethylene glycol via dual-layer polybenzimidazole (PBI)/polyetherimide (PEI) membranes, J. Membr. Sci. 378(1-2)(2011)339-350.
[44] W.X. Zhang, Y.P. Ying, J. Ma, X.Y. Guo, H.L. Huang, D.H. Liu, C.L. Zhong, Mixed matrix membranes incorporated with polydopamine-coated metal-organic framework for dehydration of ethylene glycol by pervaporation, J. Membr. Sci. 527(2017)8-17.
[45] V. Ples u, A.E. Bonet Ruiz, J. Bonet, J. Llorens, Simple equation for suitability of heat pump use in distillation, in:Computer Aided Chemical Engineering, Elsevier, Amsterdam, 2014.